As a major
Star Wars fan, I was excited and yet apprehensive for this film. Excited because it was
Star Wars and it was the first film we had gotten in 15 years. Well, no technically true. We got
Clone Wars in '08,
Sparks of Rebellion in '13 and
Siege of Lothal earlier this year. Personally, I think SOL was an excellent movie show-casing the Darth Vader we all knew and love effectively. It was also superior to the other three cartoon movies.
But as for an official Star Wars episode, this would be the first in a long time. Gone were the days as a kid that I said, "There's no way I'm watching anything more than 1-6 because it's the story of Anakin Skywalker! Lucas said so!" It is a very exciting time for the Star Wars universe and I looked forward to seeing where we had ended up.
I was however apprehensive. We were getting Abrams doing this film. And we all knew the debacle that was Star Trek Into Darkness, one of the most universally panned ST films. Even Star Trek '09 despite it's originality, made almost no sense and many fans weren't even able to finish the film because of the sheer volume of nonsense that went on. Heck, even his films Cloverfield and Super 8 were nothing to write home about and his Mission Impossible movies offer nothing in terms of original story telling, following the same basis as what had been seen in the first three movies.
|
Obviously, Abrams wasn't exactly the fans best choice for the new SW films. |
But all that said, we hold our collective breaths and plunge headlong into the movie.
Story:
We will start by talking about the story. Luke Skywalker has gone missing and two factions have arisen for two conflicting purposes. The First Order arose with a simple goal, finding and killing Luke Skywalker and ending any hope of the Jedi rising again. The Resistance was created by the backing of the New Republic to hinder the First Order and find Luke Skywalker to bring him back to the fold.
In theory I get on board with this plotline. And yet, here is where my first problem arises with the story. Why was the New Republic not completely invested in hunting down and destroying this Imperial Remnant which clearly was antagonistic? If they really had an invested interest in keeping Luke alive, why did they do really so little to protect him? But for more problems I have with the story, I'll leave it for another section.
Anyways, moving on.
The Resistance and First Order have learned that an old man on the desert planet Jakku has a piece of the map to finding Luke Skywalker. The Resistance beats the First Order there by sending their best pilot. He gets the information but barely has it before the First Order arrives. He gets captured but not before hiding it in the now famous BB-8 droid.
BB-8 escapes and finds Rey, a girl who has been abandoned by her family on Jakku, As she befriends
the little droid, she soon becomes entangled in the larger mission to save Luke Skywalker. This happens because one of the troopers who attacked the Jakku village deserts the First Order, rescues Poe Dameron the pilot and they end up crash landing on Jakku and separated, the stormtrooper deserter who has been called Finn finds them.
They escape TIE Fighter pursuit on a derelict Millennium Falcon only to be caught by a First Order transport which just happens to be piloted by Han Solo and Chewbacca, who are back in debt to gangster organizations. After a hectic three way battle between gangsters, our heroes and monsters out of Edge of Tomorrow they end up blasting away in the Falcon.
|
This is perhaps the most celebrated scene of the movie. |
When Han learns that BB-8 has a piece of the map that will help them find Luke Skywalker, he immediately decides to help them. Years have gone by and he has been converted to the ideas of the Force and has become an ardent supporter of it. But, he can't go to Leia who he has had a severe falling out from. So, he takes them to a backwater forest planet where an old friend of his can help them.
They are able to secure this aliens help, but Finn refuses to go to the Resistance, finally confessing to Rey that he's not Resistance, which he had been telling her the entire time. He's left the First Order but fears the wrath they are about to unleash. Rey's Force abilities begin to awaken as she is called by Anakin Skywalker lightsaber and we see a force vision that shows the end of the Luke Skywalker's original attempt to create a new Jedi Order. The ancient alien who Han went to seek her help, tries to convince Rey that it is her destiny to take up the calling of the Force but Rey, frightened by the implications, runs off into the woods.
Up to this point, Kylo Ren, leader of the Knights of Ren under the mysterious Supreme Commander Snoke, has been trying to track down the droid BB-8. Him and General Hux, the military leader of the First Order military, have been at odds on how to carry out this mission. General Hux convicnes Snoke it is time to demonstrate the power of their super-weapon and with his approval, destroys the government and military of the New Republic in one fell swoop. At the same time, Kylo Ren attacks and captures Rey before being beaten off by Resistance forces led by Poe Dameron.
|
The scene has the feeling of an old Western cavalry coming to the rescue. |
Han Solo and company go to the Resistance headquarters where we learn that Leia and Han had a son. This child became Kylo Ren and he destroyed Luke's New Order after being seduced by Snoke to the Dark Side. This drove the two apart even though they still obviously love each other. This also drove Luke into hiding, feeling responsible for not only allowing his nephew to fall, but also the damage done to the relationship of those he felt closest to.
They plan to destroy the superweapon, the Starkiller Base before it can wipe out the Resistance, and with Finn's knowledge of the planet-sized superweapon, they are able to damage the weakpoint enough that the Resistance pilots lead by Poe are able to destroy the superweapon. Rey starts to allow to start using her new-found Force powers and is able to escape capture.
However, during the escape and damaging the weakpoint, Han tries to convince his son whose real name is Ben, to turn from the Darkness. Kylo Ren has been conflicted, torn between the call of the Light Side and the lure of the dark path he wishes to follow. Just when Kylo seems as if he will be redeemed, he murders his father and after being wounded by Chewbacca, pursues Rey and Finn. In an epic lightsaber clash, he overwhelms Finn and nearly kills him. But Rey, finally fully embraces the Force and defeats him. She doesn't kill him but he is badly maimed. Both are rescued as the planet falls apart. One is saved by the Falcon and the other is saved by General Hux, who acting under orders of Snoke is retrieving him so that Kylo can finish his training.
|
Harrison Ford claims the battle between Rey and Kylo is his favorite scene of the movie. |
After the destruction of Starkiller base, R2 awakens and reveals he has the rest of the map that BB-8 only had a part of. From there, they learn the location of Skywalker and Rey, Chewbacca and BB-8 are chosen to go to Luke. So, they rush to the planet he is on and the movie ends with Rey standing before Luke, holding out his lightsaber to him.
Things that work well for the movie:
Let us start with the good the movie has to offer. The acting in this movie excels for the most part. There are many newcomers to the big screen, most notably Daisy Ridley, with this being her first project for the most part, besides a few minor roles on tv. But you could never tell with how she holds her own against veteran actors like Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher. The same can be said for the rest of the cast, who really play well off each other.
This leads to another point I wish to make. Abrams is a master at interpersonal relations. It was a genuine thrill to see the interactions between Oscar Issac's Poe Dameron and John Boyegas' Finn, Finn and Daisy Ridleys' Rey, Rey with Harrison's Han Solo. Even Adam Driver's Kylo Ren and Domnhall Gleeson's General Hux worked very well together, even though they were villains.
|
Very epic pieces of dialogue can be found in the movie. |
The writing for the movie was very stong. There were some parts they didn't make much sense, but the most part, the dialogue was exactly what was needed and they towed the fine line between witty and seriousness masterfully.
This also feels like a natural progression of technology. A big complaint about the PT is that the tech is so much more advanced that in the OT. My personal theory is that Palpatine actually banned the advancement of tech except for his military so people were forced to watch the tech they had degrade. It's also my belief that there was a gender purge as well, which would account for the lack of so many of the female gender.
|
It felt indeed like 30 years had passed, |
This did feel like a natural progression of society. The Jedi are basically a myth, something that they were in the OT, only this time, it is more commonly accepted at the level of the Knights of the Round Table. The Galaxy seems to have more or less moved on from the need of the Force, even though Factions realize it's potential.
By the end of the movie, it left me feeling very hopeful for the next movie. You have Rey meeting Luke and we are hopefully going to see Luke as the teacher. We will meet Supreme Commander Snoke and I hope he will be revealed as Darth Plagueis the Wise who faked his own death, even to a Sith as powerful as Sidious. We will also see something we have never seen before.....a dark sider being trained.
Things that didn't work so well:
Despite the strength of the film, they fell extremely short in several regards.
One of the worst decisions in the movie was to hype Gwendoline Christies' character. Captain Phasma was made in the trailers to be far more formidable and a bit more involved in the story then what we got. Her character was so underplayed that was all but a nonentity. In fact, we all but forget about her because she simply has no bearing on the story.
|
Why make such a big deal out of her if you weren't going to really use her? |
Another was their seeming desire to rush Adam Driver's character. Kylo Ren failed in many regards because Abrams and company wanted to rush his origins and backstory. They stripped away the mystery of the character far too swiftly and we were left not with an imposing figure that the layers of his complexity were revealed in a good pace, to a character rushed, taking away much of the power of his persona.
Fin was also misused. There is no sense that he was a programmed trooper who broke his conditioning. He seemed more to have been someone who had never fully been convinced of the rightness of the Cause and it just seemed that Abrams and company never really knew what they wanted to do with him. I truly never felt he had been a true believer, despite his claims.
|
At least Finn wasn't always out of breath and sweating like the trailers made it out to be, |
In the story section, I mentioned the sheer minimalist support the New Republic gave the Resistance. If Luke was so important, why did they do so little to safeguard him? This bleeds over into another problem I had with the movie. How was it possible that the entire military of the New Republic and it's entire government could be wiped out by a single blow? Are you really saying that there wasn't senators that were out of town visiting their own systems or on diplomatic missions? Was there really no fleets of patrol ships patrolling the Republic's borders? The level of sheer incompetence is not realistic and is a serious flub in the story.
Why did R2-D2 wait until Starkiller Base was destroyed before coming back to life with the rest of the map? Wouldn't he want his old master to be found as soon as possible? In fact, why couldn't the Resistance use existing starcharts, compare them to the piece of the map BB-8 brought? Sure, it's not a part of space they know, but surely they can use what they've got and figure it out.
They also mishandled the revel of Luke. It was never going to meet the hype, but the music they used for it was subdued, and in no ways did it fit the tone that there should have been for the moment the whole film had been building towards. In fact, the whole scene felt very anti-climatic.
I also had a problem with the First Order. There seemed to be no goals of the First Order beside the elimination of the Jedi. The destruction of the New Republic government did not seem so much to be for an actual bid for getting a better political position in the galaxy at large, but merely as a tool to prevent the Resistance from their meddling in the destruction of Luke Skywalker. In fact, for the Heirs to the Empire, they seemed to have no real grand purpose beyond extinguishing the light, making the whole regime feel utterly one-dimensional.
|
You have the ability to easily defeat the New Republic and yet you squander it merely on hunting a single Jedi? |
Originality of the story:
What originality? I have heard people on Facebook comment on it, "It's Episode IV, only with better graphics." And that's utterly true, although they use plot elements from other movies as well. This isn't surprising, as Abrams was never a master at original stories.
Lets count a few ways this is true.
- Abandoned girl on desert planet finds a droid carrying important secret document. Orphaned boy on desert planet finds a droid carrying important secret documents.
|
Abrams was never a master at originality. |
- Stormtrooper rescues rebel pilot from Star Destroyer. Luke disguised as stormtrooper rescues Leia from Death Star.
- Rey is a master at fixing equipment and flying ships. Anakin Skywalker is a master at fixing equipment and flying ship.
- First Order has a super-weapon that can destroy several planets. Empire has a super-weapon that can destroy plants.
|
I think they understood the non-originality of the story by having Ackbar even point it out. |
- Starkiller base has building that is weakness that can be destroyed with missiles. Death Star has exhaust shaft that can be destroyed by missiles.
- Kylo Ren can communicate to his master in holocommunications in scenes very similar to the ESB Vader's chamber scene. They even have a conversation very similar. "There is a great disturbance in the Force." "I have felt it."/"There has been an awakening? Have you felt it?" "Yes."
- Both VII and IV open with a stormtrooper attack that wipes out the defenders. One takes place with a ship-to-ship boarding, the other is a planet-side landing.
- Both Poe Dameron and Princess Leia hide the secret plans in a droid.
- Episodes I, IV and VII all have a mentor being slaughtered before the eyes of their proteges.
- Episodes III, V, VI and VII have a "Come with me" speech. III, VI and VII revolves around, "Come away with me and abandon the dark side. V and VII take place on a bridge.
- IV, V and VII both have Jedi that are self-exiled. Both V and VII the young Jedi-to-be must go search out the Jedi Master.
Need I go on? I left the movie theater with an odd lack of feeling any originality from this film. This happened in STID and the Mission Impossible movies. Heck, even Colverfield felt nothing more than an alternate version of the Blair Witch Project. The one major movie that seems to break that mold Star Trek '09 had so many plot holes you could fly the Enterprise through. Or, if we want to keep in line with Star Wars references, it had as big a holes in it as the Second Death Star.
In summary:
As a movie, it was a thrill to watch. The acting was more or less incredible and there was never a dull moment. It feels like Star Wars. Yet don't expect to come away feeling anything as if this will reshape the entire franchise.